Skip to main content

Privacy

A note about cookies

Essential cookies keep this site running. Optional analytics help us understand what's working, only enabled if you accept.

LIBRARY
United StatesVariationsJurisdiction article

Cardinal change in the United States

A cardinal change is an alteration so drastic that it effectively requires the contractor to perform duties materially different from those originally bargained for. It falls outside the changes clause, so it is a breach of contract rather than a change to be priced under it.

Reviewed Sep 22, 202617 min read28 sources

At a glance

United States
Jurisdiction
United States, federal doctrine; state reception thin and uneven
Governing authority
Rumsfeld v Freedom NY (test) · FAR 52.243-4(a) / AIA A201–2017 §7.3.1 (textual hook) · Alliant Techsystems (duty to proceed)
The myth this page corrects
"Nine states adopted, four rejected" does not survive a check against the cases, only one state high court has expressly adopted the doctrine
Evidence basis
Federal Circuit, Court of Claims, Court of Federal Claims, CBCA and GAO decisions read directly; state appellate and federal-prediction decisions checked case by case
§ 00

Key facts

  1. 01

    The test has no formula

    "An alteration in the work so drastic that it effectively requires the contractor to perform duties materially different from those originally bargained for." Rumsfeld v Freedom NY, Inc, 329 F.3d 1320, 1332 (Fed. Cir. 2003). Cardinality is principally a question of fact, won or lost on the project record.

  2. 02

    A cost multiple alone rarely clears the threshold

    A $100 million increase on a $60 million contract was within scope (General Dynamics, as described in Miller Elevator); a treble rise in cost was outside it (Kiewit). "No rule of thumb exists." Plead a change of kind, not of degree.

  3. 03

    The remedy is breach damages, not a blank cheque

    Amelco Electric v City of Thousand Oaks, 27 Cal. 4th 228 (2002): no authority holds contract terms "inapplicable or set aside" for the period before the breach. Assume release, cap and no-damage-for-delay clauses survive unless your forum has held otherwise.

  4. 04

    The duty to proceed falls away only if you are right

    Alliant Techsystems, Inc v United States, 178 F.3d 1260, 1275–76 (Fed. Cir. 1999): a cardinal change frees the contractor from the Disputes clause's duty to proceed — but on its own facts Alliant found no drastic modification, and Alliant had to keep performing.

  5. 05

    Amelco decided three things, and no more

    Abandonment is unavailable against a public entity; the rule is confined to public entities (it survives between private parties); and whether cardinal change itself applies in California was left open.

  6. 06

    Two waiver rules get conflated, and they are not the same rule

    Whether signed modifications released the cardinal-change claim turns on the release wording. Blue & Gold Fleet, L.P. v United States, 492 F.3d 1308 (Fed. Cir. 2007), is a bid-protest waiver rule for a would-be offeror — not a cardinal-change rule, whatever the commentary implies.

  7. 07

    An out-of-scope modification is also an unlawful sole-source procurement

    The protest mirror runs through the Competition in Contracting Act. A sustained protest can end with the work being competed away — and the state-law version can be harsher: a New York court ordered a contractor to refund the difference between its negotiated price and a competed price.

  8. 08

    "Nine adopted, four rejected" does not survive a check

    Only Nevada has expressly adopted the doctrine at state high-court level. Maine, Oklahoma and Wyoming's high courts engaged with it and declined on the facts; Ohio, Mississippi and New Jersey are federal predictions, not state holdings. Most states are undecided.

Every changes clause has an outer edge. Inside it, the owner orders and the contractor performs and is paid through the clause. Past it, the owner is no longer exercising a contract right — it is in breach. US law calls that a cardinal change. It is a US doctrine; other systems police the same boundary through the wording of the variation power. The doctrine takes a sentence to state. The remedy — breach damages, a right to stop, or reasonable value with the contract set aside — depends on forum, state and owner, and is most of this page.

Cardinal change is often confused with constructive change, which is a different doctrine with a different remedy. See constructive change in the United States.

A note on sources. FAR clauses were read on acquisition.gov (FAC 2026-01). Read the clause as incorporated in your contract, not the FAR — the FAR Overhaul runs through agency class deviations. Case quotations were checked against published texts of the opinions; where only commentary was available, the page says so.

§ 01

The short answer

The textual hook is FAR 52.243-4 (JUN 2007), paragraph (a). Under it the Contracting Officer may "make changes in the work within the general scope of the contract." An order outside that scope is not authorised by the clause. The clause therefore cannot compel the work or supply the price, so the claim becomes a claim for breach.

The Federal Circuit's standard formulation is in Rumsfeld v Freedom NY, Inc1, quoting Krygoski Construction Co. v United States, 94 F.3d 1537, 1543 (Fed. Cir. 1996). A cardinal change "occurs when the government effects an alteration in the work so drastic that it effectively requires the contractor to perform duties materially different from those originally bargained for."

Two policies drive it, and only one travels: protecting the contractor from a different bargain, and protecting competitive procurement from a sole-source contract created by modification. The second is the source of the protest mirror below and has no private-work counterpart — one reason the doctrine sits less securely in state law.

Cardinal change is not constructive change. A constructive change is in-scope work ordered informally and priced under the clause, subject to FAR 52.243-4(b)'s notice condition. A cardinal change is out-of-scope work that the clause cannot redress; it sounds in breach.

§ 02

The test

There is no formula. The key authorities are Wunderlich Contracting Co. v United States2, quoted for "giving just consideration to the magnitude and quality of the changes ordered and their cumulative effect upon the project as a whole"; Edward R. Marden Corp. v United States3, quoted in Freedom NY for "it is the entire undertaking of the contractor, rather than the product, to which we look" — a cardinal change can occur even when the finished product is the same; and Air-A-Plane Corp. v United States4, asking whether the modified job is essentially the same work the parties bargained for.

Becho, Inc. v United States5 stated that there is "no precise calculus," and listed the factors courts weigh: whether the magnitude of the work changed significantly; whether the change procures a totally different item or drastically alters the quality, character, nature or type of work; whether the cost of the ordered work greatly exceeds the original price.

Cardinality is principally a question of fact (Becho), so it is won or lost on the project record, rarely on a motion.

§ 03

The threshold is very high, and a cost multiple alone rarely clears it

Magnitude is a factor. It is almost never enough by itself. The cases turn on whether the kind of undertaking changed.

CaseFactsResult
General Dynamics Corp. v United States6As described in Miller Elevator: a $100 million increase on a $60 million contractWithin scope
Miller Elevator Co. v United States7A $75,615 claim on a $212,940 elevator-maintenance contract (about 35%); "the same nature of work … (albeit of a different scope)"Not cardinal
Peter Kiewit Sons' Co. v Summit Construction Co.8As described in Miller Elevator: a treble rise in costOutside scope
Saddler v United States9Levee; embankment volume more than doubled and length roughly doubled after a redesignCardinal, despite a signed change order
Edward R. Marden Corp.3Hangar collapsed during erection; reconstruction at nearly double the contract priceClaim not one encompassed by the Changes clause; left to be tried as breach
In re Boston Shipyard Corp.10Open-and-inspect ship repair; 86 later change ordersNot cardinal: predictable for that type of contract
Rumsfeld v Freedom NY1Payment delays, financing interference, inspection problemsNot cardinal: compensable breaches, not materially different duties

Miller Elevator put General Dynamics and Kiewit side by side to make the point: "No rule of thumb exists." An increase of roughly 167% was within scope; a treble rise in cost was not.

The working view: plead a change of kind, not of degree. Show that the method, risk profile, trades or skills became something the bid did not contemplate, and that the contract documents did not warn of it. Cost growth supports the case; it is not the case. Two traps: in open-and-inspect, indefinite-quantity or design-development contracts, heavy change is the bargain (Boston Shipyard); and a long list of modifications shows transformation but also shows the changes were being administered through the clause.

§ 04

What a finding actually gets you — the remedy question

Three different remedies are in play, and the cases do not always keep them apart.

RemedyWhat it givesWhereThe catch
Breach (cardinal change proper)Damages for material breach; anticipatory profit if prevented from performing (Allied Materials)Federal; Nevada for private work; elsewhere see belowContract terms generally govern the period before the breach (Amelco). Not necessarily quantum meruit
Stop work / treat as repudiationRelease from further performance, including the Disputes-clause duty to proceed (Alliant)Wherever the doctrine appliesOnly if you are right. If you are wrong, you have abandoned the contract
AbandonmentContract treated as set aside; reasonable value for all the workState law, mostly private work. Not against a California public entityA different doctrine with different elements

The federal position. A cardinal change is a material breach, and the Federal Circuit has said such a breach frees the contractor from its contract obligations, including those under the Disputes clause: Alliant Techsystems, Inc. v United States11. The obligation that matters is FAR 52.233-1 (MAY 2014)(i): the Contractor "shall proceed diligently with performance of this contract, pending final resolution of any request for relief, claim, appeal, or action arising under the contract, and comply with any decision of the Contracting Officer." Alternate I (DEC 1991) widens it to disputes "arising under or relating to" the contract. [EDITION ALERT] The proposed Part 33 rule, FAR Case 2026-001 (23 June 2026), would remove paragraph (i) in favour of the Alternate I language. Check your contract's text.

But on its facts Alliant found no drastic modification, so Alliant had to keep performing. The release belongs only to a contractor who is right.

The dilemma. Allied Materials & Equipment Co. v United States12: "The cautious contractor might often proceed under the revised contract because of doubt whether he could invoke the cardinal change doctrine." Boston Shipyard shows why: the yard stopped work, called the changes cardinal, and lost — they were not. Performing has a price too. In Fuller Co. v Brown Minneapolis Tank & Fabricating Co.13, a subcontractor that continued after assumed cardinal changes had made an election: it stayed bound by the contract's terms and was left to damages. On federal work a declaration is available — Alliant upheld Court of Federal Claims jurisdiction over a pre-performance non-monetary claim under 28 U.S.C. § 1491(a)(2) — but the same opinion held the contractor had to keep working meanwhile.

So: perform under protest, reserve specifically on every modification, segregate costs from the day scope moved, and litigate cardinality afterwards.

The measure is breach damages, not a blank cheque. It is often said that a finding makes every contractual limitation fall away. The authorities located do not go that far. Amelco Electric v City of Thousand Oaks14: "There is no hint in any Federal Circuit or Court of Claims case to which we have been directed that the terms of the federal contract are held inapplicable or set aside for the period prior to the breach." Litton Systems, Inc. v Frigitemp Corp.15: even if the doctrine applied, relief would be breach damages, not quantum meruit. SINGLE-SOURCE Turner Construction Co. v M.J. Flaherty Co. (Mass. Super. Ct. 2017) is reported to have held that a cardinal change did not displace a consequential-damages waiver.

The working view: the duty to proceed falls away if you are right; notice and pricing machinery arguably do not reach work the clause never authorised; but assume other risk-allocation terms — consequential-damages waivers, caps, no-damage-for-delay clauses — survive unless your forum has held otherwise.

Sureties. FAR 52.243-4(a) dispenses with notice to sureties only for changes "within the general scope of the contract." (Inference.) An out-of-scope change falls outside the surety's advance consent — the basis of the surety-discharge defence. Check the bond's own wording.

§ 05

California: Amelco, stated precisely

The Court of Appeal, Amelco Electric v City of Thousand Oaks, 82 Cal. App. 4th 373, 98 Cal. Rptr. 2d 159 (2000), upheld recovery against a city on an abandonment theory. It was reversed: Amelco Electric v City of Thousand Oaks14. Anything still citing the 2000 decision for the abandonment theory is citing bad law. The Supreme Court held three things, and no more:

  1. Abandonment is unavailable against a public entity. The court concluded that "the theory of abandonment does not apply against a public entity"; otherwise "the notion of competitive bidding would become meaningless."
  2. The rule is confined to public entities. The California abandonment cases (Opdyke & Butler v Silver, 111 Cal. App. 2d 912; C. Norman Peterson Co. v Container Corp. of America, 172 Cal. App. 3d 628) were distinguished "on the ground they involved private, not public, parties." Abandonment survives between private parties — including a subcontractor against its prime on a public job: Sehulster Tunnels/Pre-Con v Traylor Brothers, Inc./Obayashi Corp., 111 Cal. App. 4th 1328 (2003).
  3. Cardinal change was left open: "We therefore do not reach the issues of whether the cardinal change theory applies in California."

Amelco's total-cost damages also failed for a separate reason — it never showed it was not responsible for the added costs.

What Amelco is not: a general US rule, or a rejection of cardinal change. Elsewhere, whether abandonment runs against a public owner is that state's question. In California, against a public entity, plead breach — cardinal change as breach — not abandonment. The competitive-bidding reasoning is the same reasoning behind the protest mirror below.

§ 06

The waiver problem — two rules that get conflated

Did signing the modifications waive the cardinal change?

Both lines are live.

Barring the claim. Williams Building Co. v Department of State16: bilateral modifications addressing the very document substitution later called cardinal released "any and all liability." Watt Plumbing, Air Conditioning & Electric, Inc. v Tulsa Rig, Reel & Manufacturing Co.17: "An alteration of a contract cannot constitute a breach of contract because it becomes a part of the contract." In Boston Shipyard the signed modification was an accord and satisfaction of the claims then existing; the cardinal argument about later changes failed on its merits.

Not barring the claim. In Saddler the contractor protested, signed the change order, accepted final payment — and still recovered. Atlantic Dry Dock Corp. v United States18 refused summary judgment despite some 130 change orders: the releases on their face reached only claims arising out of each modification, and a cumulative cardinal effect cannot be known until the project is complete or nearly so.

The reconciliation: read the release words (a release confined to the priced change leaves the cumulative claim alive; an "any and all liability" release addressed to the same facts does not), and ask whether the cumulative effect was knowable at signature. Same analysis, same drafting discipline, as change order releases: reserve cumulative impact and cardinality expressly, on every modification.

Blue & Gold — a bid-protest rule, not a cardinal-change rule

Blue & Gold Fleet, L.P. v United States19: a party that could have objected to a patent error in a solicitation before the close of bidding, and did not, waives it in a later Court of Federal Claims protest. Utech, Inc. v United States20: the close of bidding is the proposal submission deadline, not award.

[CONFLICT] — framing error. Blue & Gold is sometimes presented as "the cardinal-change waiver problem." It involves a different party (a would-be offeror), forum (a protest) and remedy (setting aside a procurement). Its relative, the pre-bid duty to inquire about patent ambiguities, does appear in scope disputes — as the owner's answer to "it was never in scope," not as a post-award waiver of a cardinal change.

§ 07

The protest mirror — an out-of-scope modification is an unlawful sole-source procurement

Under the Competition in Contracting Act (41 U.S.C. § 3301; for defence agencies, 10 U.S.C. § 3201), a modification beyond the original scope is in substance a new procurement awarded without competition. AT&T Communications, Inc. v Wiltel, Inc.21 drew the line in cardinal-change terms but recast the question: not whether the government breached, but whether the modification changed the contract enough to circumvent the statutory requirement of competition — including whether the solicitation adequately advised offerors of the potential for that type of change. (The Wiltel modification was held within scope.)

GAO does not generally review contract administration (4 C.F.R. § 21.5(a)), but makes an exception "where a protest alleges that a contract modification changes the work from the scope of the original contract." Zodiac of North America, Inc.22 weighs "the extent of any changes in the type of work, performance period, and costs"; "whether the original solicitation adequately advised offerors of the potential for the change or whether the change was the type that reasonably could have been anticipated"; and "whether the modification materially changed the field of competition." The best-known sustain, Leupold Stevens, Inc.23, involved a design change the solicitation expressly prohibited and about $9.3 million added to a roughly $12 million contract.

NEGATIVE FINDING No 2024–2026 GAO or Court of Federal Claims decision sustaining an out-of-scope-modification protest was located in two targeted searches on 22 September 2026 — not a finding that none exists.

Why a contractor should care:

  1. Your out-of-scope modification can be taken away. A sustained protest can end with the work being competed. The state-law version is harsher: in Albert Elia Building Co. v New York State Urban Development Corp.24, a disappointed contractor challenged a tunnel change order as unbid work; the court held it a new undertaking and ordered the contractor that built it to refund the difference between its negotiated price and what a bidding contractor would have charged.
  2. Expect the owner to run the mirror as a defence — "if this were cardinal we could not have ordered it from you, so it is in scope." The tests share vocabulary but serve opposite parties; a modification can be in scope for protest purposes yet cardinal as between the parties, and vice versa.
  3. Keep your positions consistent. "In scope" to defeat a protest and "cardinal" in your breach claim will be quoted against each other.
§ 08

State-law reception is not uniform

The circulating statistic — nine states adopted, four rejected — does not survive a check against the cases. The adopting list mixes state high-court holdings, federal predictions of state law, cases that applied the test only to find no cardinal change, and abandonment cases. The rejecting list is entirely federal predictions.

StateAuthorityWhat it doesStatus
NevadaJ.A. Jones Construction Co. v Lehrer McGovern Bovis, Inc.25Supreme court: "this cause of action is viable in the context of private construction contracts"✔ Adopted — the only state high-court adoption located
WashingtonHensel Phelps Construction Co. v King County26Applied the Air-A-Plane test; no cardinal change◐ Applied, not expressly adopted
MarylandWestinghouse Electric Corp. v Garrett Corp., 437 F. Supp. 1301 (D. Md. 1977)Federal court, Maryland law, supply subcontract; stated the doctrine from federal procurement law◐ Federal recognition only
PennsylvaniaFuller Co.Federal court assumed cardinal changes; decided on election◐ Assumed, not held
KentuckyL.K. Comstock & Co. v Becon Construction Co., 932 F. Supp. 906 (E.D. Ky. 1993)Special master's report with a section headed "'Engrafting' Cardinal Change onto Kentucky Law?"UNVERIFIED holding not read
ArkansasHousing Authority of Texarkana v E.W. Johnson Construction Co., 264 Ark. 523, 573 S.W.2d 316 (1978)Affirmed trial findings of "cardinal changes" on a public project; the reasoning rests on implied warranty of plans◐ Affirmed findings using the term; whether that is an adoption is contested
IndianaRudd v Anderson, 153 Ind. App. 11, 285 N.E.2d 836 (1972)Reasonable value after extensive changes — abandonment-type, not cardinal change by name✗ Off the list
OklahomaWatt PlumbingSupreme court recognised the doctrine in principle and held it inapplicable where the subcontractor agreed to perform the changes for an agreed price◐ Recognised in principle; not applied
MaineClaude Dubois Excavating, Inc. v Town of Kittery27Supreme Judicial Court applied the federal "general scope" test and declined "to apply the so-called 'cardinal change' doctrine to this contract," because the contract allowed the Town to reduce quantities◐ Engaged; declined on the facts
WyomingScherer Construction, LLC v Hedquist Construction, Inc.28Supreme court stated the federal rule — "a cardinal change is a breach" — but declined to extend it to a main contractor that did not order the change (the City changed asphalt to concrete): "We decline to extend the doctrine to include third parties who happen to be parties to the contract."◐ Stated; not extended to a non-ordering prime
OhioEbenisterie Beaubois Ltée v Marous Bros. Construction, Inc., 2002 WL 32818011 (N.D. Ohio)Predicted the Ohio Supreme Court would not recognise the claim✔ Declined (federal prediction)
MississippiLitton Systems"Mississippi does not subscribe to the cardinal change doctrine"✔ Rejected (federal prediction)
New JerseyDurr Mechanical Construction, Inc. v PSEG Fossil, LLC, 516 F. Supp. 3d 407 (D.N.J. 2021)No New Jersey precedent; "it is not the role of a federal court to expand state law in ways not foreshadowed by state precedent"✔ Declined (federal prediction)
IllinoisMellon Stuart Construction v Metropolitan Water Reclamation District, 1995 WL 124133 (N.D. Ill.)One secondary reports a refusal; another survey lists Illinois the other way; opinion not read✗ Off the list — SINGLE-SOURCE CONFLICT

Hancock Electronics Corp. v Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority, 81 F.3d 451 (4th Cir. 1996), often counted as an adoption, is not a state authority at all: the Fourth Circuit applied federal government-contract principles to a transit authority's contract, and found no cardinal change.

What the table supports: only Nevada has expressly adopted the doctrine at state high-court level (private work). The high courts of Maine, Oklahoma and Wyoming have discussed it and declined to apply it on the facts; three federal courts have predicted that Ohio, Mississippi and New Jersey would not recognise it; California has left it open. In most other states it is undecided. Check your own state's high court before pleading — a state that has not adopted the doctrine may still have spoken to it, as Maine and Wyoming have.

★ Subcontractors, read Scherer. The claim a subcontractor most often wants to bring is cardinal change against a prime contractor for changes the owner ordered. Wyoming's supreme court has declined to extend the doctrine to exactly that defendant. (Opinion.) Where the prime did not order the change, plead the pass-through and the subcontract's own changes and pricing machinery, not cardinal change against the prime alone. Plead in the alternative — breach of the changes clause, abandonment where available against that owner, quantum meruit where the contract is displaced. (Semac Electric Co. v Skanska USA Building, Inc., 195 Conn. App. 695 (2020), an intermediate appellate court, is described by commentators both as recognising the doctrine and as rejecting the claim on its facts; it is not scored here.)

§ 09

Checklist before you plead it

  1. Find the limiter in your changes clause — "within the general scope" or its equivalent (FAR 52.243-4(a); on AIA work, A201–2017 §7.3.1 lets the Owner order changes by Construction Change Directive "within the general scope of the Contract"). No limiter, no textual hook.
  2. Prove kind, not degree: undertaking as bid against undertaking as performed. Cost last.
  3. Say "cardinal" in writing, early, with reasons — and on federal work preserve the FAR 52.243-4(b) constructive-change route in the alternative.
  4. Keep performing and reserve on every modification, unless you are certain.
  5. Check owner type and state — California public entity: breach, not abandonment.
Notes

Sources and authorities

28 cited
  1. 1
    Rumsfeld v Freedom NY, Inc329 F.3d 1320, 1332 (Fed. Cir. 2003), quoting Krygoski Construction Co v United States, 94 F.3d 1537, 1543 (Fed. Cir. 1996), United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

    A cardinal change "occurs when the government effects an alteration in the work so drastic that it effectively requires the contractor to perform duties materially different from those originally bargained for." On its facts, payment delays, financing interference and inspection problems were compensable breaches, not a cardinal change.

    Justia

  2. 2
    Wunderlich Contracting Co. v United States351 F.2d 956, 966 (Ct. Cl. 1965), Court of Claims

    "Each case must be analyzed on its own facts and in light of its own circumstances, giving just consideration to the magnitude and quality of the changes ordered and their cumulative effect upon the project as a whole."

    Find on CourtListener

  3. 3
    Edward R. Marden Corp. v United States442 F.2d 364, 370 (Ct. Cl. 1971), Court of Claims

    "It is the entire undertaking of the contractor, rather than the product, to which we look" — a cardinal change can occur even when the finished product is the same. A hangar collapsed during erection and was reconstructed at nearly double the contract price; the claim was "not one encompassed by the Changes clause" and was remanded to be tried as breach.

    Find on CourtListener

  4. 4
    Air-A-Plane Corp. v United States408 F.2d 1030, 1033 (Ct. Cl. 1969), Court of Claims

    The recurring question is whether the modified job is essentially the same work the parties bargained for.

    Find on CourtListener

  5. 5
    Becho, Inc. v United States47 Fed. Cl. 595, 601 (2000), United States Court of Federal Claims

    There is "no precise calculus." Courts weigh whether the magnitude of the work changed significantly, whether the change procures a totally different item or drastically alters the quality, character, nature or type of work, and whether the cost greatly exceeds the original price. Cardinality is principally a question of fact.

    Find on CourtListener

  6. 6
    General Dynamics Corp. v United States585 F.2d 457 (Ct. Cl. 1978), Court of Claims

    A $100 million increase on a $60 million contract was held within scope.

    Find on CourtListener

  7. 7
    Miller Elevator Co. v United States30 Fed. Cl. 662 (1994), United States Court of Federal Claims

    A $75,615 claim on a $212,940 elevator-maintenance contract (roughly 35%) was "the same nature of work … (albeit of a different scope)" and not cardinal. Put side by side with General Dynamics and Kiewit to show "no rule of thumb exists."

    Find on CourtListener

  8. 8
    Peter Kiewit Sons' Co. v Summit Construction Co.422 F.2d 242, 255 (8th Cir. 1969), United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit

    A treble rise in cost was held outside the original scope.

    Find on CourtListener

  9. 9
    Saddler v United States287 F.2d 411 (Ct. Cl. 1961), Court of Claims

    Embankment volume more than doubled and length roughly doubled after a redesign of a levee. Held cardinal, despite a signed change order, and despite the contractor having protested, signed and accepted final payment.

    Find on CourtListener

  10. 10
    In re Boston Shipyard Corp.886 F.2d 451 (1st Cir. 1989), United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit

    An open-and-inspect ship-repair contract drew 86 later change orders and was held not cardinal — that volume of change was predictable for that type of contract. The yard's own earlier modification was an accord and satisfaction of the claims then existing; its cardinal argument about later changes failed on the merits.

    Find on CourtListener

  11. 11
    Alliant Techsystems, Inc. v United States178 F.3d 1260, 1275–76 (Fed. Cir. 1999), United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

    A cardinal change is a material breach that frees the contractor from its contract obligations, including the Disputes clause's duty to proceed — and the Court of Federal Claims has jurisdiction over a pre-performance, non-monetary declaratory claim under 28 U.S.C. § 1491(a)(2). On its own facts the court found no drastic modification, so Alliant itself had to keep performing.

    Find on CourtListener

  12. 12
    Allied Materials & Equipment Co. v United States569 F.2d 562, 563–64 (Ct. Cl. 1978), Court of Claims

    "The cautious contractor might often proceed under the revised contract because of doubt whether he could invoke the cardinal change doctrine" — and can recover anticipatory profit if prevented from performing.

    Find on CourtListener

  13. 13
    Fuller Co. v Brown Minneapolis Tank & Fabricating Co.678 F. Supp. 506 (E.D. Pa. 1987), United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania

    A subcontractor that continued performing after assumed cardinal changes made an election: it stayed bound by the contract's terms and was left to damages.

    Find on CourtListener

  14. 14
    Amelco Electric v City of Thousand Oaks27 Cal. 4th 228, 38 P.3d 1120 (2002), Supreme Court of California, reversing 82 Cal. App. 4th 373 (2000)

    Abandonment is unavailable against a public entity, because otherwise "the notion of competitive bidding would become meaningless." The rule is confined to public entities; California's abandonment cases were distinguished as involving private parties. Whether the cardinal-change theory itself applies in California was expressly left open. "There is no hint in any Federal Circuit or Court of Claims case … that the terms of the federal contract are held inapplicable or set aside for the period prior to the breach."

    Find on CourtListener

  15. 15
    Litton Systems, Inc. v Frigitemp Corp.613 F. Supp. 1377 (S.D. Miss. 1985), United States District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi

    "Mississippi does not subscribe to the cardinal change doctrine" — a federal prediction, not a state holding. Even if the doctrine applied, relief would be breach damages, not quantum meruit.

    Find on CourtListener

  16. 16
    Williams Building Co. v Department of StateCBCA 6650, 7147 (26 April 2023), aff'd, No. 23-2337 (Fed. Cir. 23 July 2025) (nonprecedential), Civilian Board of Contract Appeals

    Bilateral modifications addressing the very document substitution later called cardinal released "any and all liability" — barring the claim.

    Find on CBCA

  17. 17
    Watt Plumbing, Air Conditioning & Electric, Inc. v Tulsa Rig, Reel & Manufacturing Co.533 P.2d 980, 983 (Okla. 1975), Supreme Court of Oklahoma

    "An alteration of a contract cannot constitute a breach of contract because it becomes a part of the contract." Recognised the doctrine in principle but held it inapplicable, because the subcontractor had agreed to perform the changes for an agreed price.

    Find on CourtListener

  18. 18
    Atlantic Dry Dock Corp. v United States773 F. Supp. 335, 339–40 (M.D. Fla. 1991), United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida

    Refused summary judgment despite some 130 change orders: the releases on their face reached only claims arising out of each modification, and a cumulative cardinal effect cannot be known until the project is complete or nearly so.

    Find on CourtListener

  19. 19
    Blue & Gold Fleet, L.P. v United States492 F.3d 1308, 1313–15 (Fed. Cir. 2007), United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

    A party that could have objected to a patent error in a solicitation before the close of bidding, and did not, waives it in a later Court of Federal Claims bid protest.

    Find on CourtListener

  20. 20
    Utech, Inc. v United StatesNo. 24-1586 (Fed. Cir., 24 June 2026) (nonprecedential), United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

    The close of bidding for Blue & Gold purposes is the proposal submission deadline, not award.

    Find on CourtListener

  21. 21
    AT&T Communications, Inc. v Wiltel, Inc.1 F.3d 1201, 1205 (Fed. Cir. 1993), United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

    Drew the scope line in cardinal-change terms but recast the question for the protest mirror: not whether the government breached, but whether the modification changed the contract enough to circumvent the statutory requirement of competition. The modification at issue was held within scope.

    Find on CourtListener

  22. 22
    Zodiac of North America, Inc.B-414260 (28 March 2017), Government Accountability Office

    GAO reviews an out-of-scope-modification protest despite its general rule against reviewing contract administration, weighing the extent of changes in type of work, performance period and costs; whether the solicitation adequately advised offerors of the potential for the change; and whether the modification materially changed the field of competition. Protest denied on the facts.

  23. 23
    Leupold Stevens, Inc.B-417796 (30 October 2019), Government Accountability Office

    The best-known sustain of an out-of-scope-modification protest: a design change the solicitation expressly prohibited, adding about $9.3 million to a roughly $12 million contract.

  24. 24
    Albert Elia Building Co. v New York State Urban Development Corp.54 A.D.2d 337, 388 N.Y.S.2d 462 (4th Dep't 1976), New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division

    A disappointed competitor challenged a tunnel change order as unbid work; the court held it a new undertaking and ordered the contractor that built it to refund the difference between its negotiated price and what a bidding contractor would have charged.

  25. 25
    J.A. Jones Construction Co v Lehrer McGovern Bovis, Inc120 Nev. 277, 89 P.3d 1009 (2004), Supreme Court of Nevada

    The only state high-court decision located expressly adopting cardinal change, holding the cause of action "viable in the context of private construction contracts."

    Find on CourtListener

  26. 26
    Hensel Phelps Construction Co. v King County57 Wn. App. 170, 787 P.2d 58 (1990), Washington Court of Appeals

    Applied the Air-A-Plane test and found no cardinal change. Applied the test without expressly adopting the doctrine as Washington law.

    Find on CourtListener

  27. 27
    Claude Dubois Excavating, Inc. v Town of Kittery634 A.2d 1299 (Me. 1993), Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

    Applied the federal "general scope" test and declined to apply the cardinal-change doctrine to the facts, because the contract allowed the Town to reduce quantities.

    Find on CourtListener

  28. 28
    Scherer Construction, LLC v Hedquist Construction, Inc.18 P.3d 645, 2001 WY 23, Supreme Court of Wyoming

    Stated the federal rule — "a cardinal change is a breach" — but declined to extend it to a main contractor that did not itself order the change: "We decline to extend the doctrine to include third parties who happen to be parties to the contract."

    Find on CourtListener

General information, not legal advice. Reviewed Sep 22, 2026. Spotted an error? info@storiatechnologies.com

Newsletter · monthly

The notice brief

One email a month on claims, notices and the cases that decided them.

One email a month. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share your address.

The notice briefIssue 01 · sample

This month: three notice clocks and their judgments.

  1. 01
    Notice and time bars in OntarioIn Ontario a contractual notice of delay is a condition precedent: miss it and the claim is…
  2. 02
    Notice and time bars in AustraliaAustralian EOT time bars are enforceable conditions precedent everywhere, subject to the…
  3. 03
    Delay notice templates for AS 4000, FIDIC 2017 and CCDC 2A delay notice puts one fact on the record in time: that something has delayed, or will delay,…

Each issue links to the full articles in the Storia Library.

Cardinal change in construction: the US test and remedies · Storia