No-Damage-for-Delay Clauses: Enforceable in Texas, Void in Ohio
A no-damage-for-delay (NDFD) clause limits a contractor's delay remedy to a time extension only. US enforceability is not uniform: it turns on state law, judicially created exceptions, and, in a minority of states, statutory override that can void the clause outright.
Disponible en anglais seulement Cet article n'a pas encore été traduit. Les délais, le droit à réclamation et la procédure décrits ici touchent au droit, et une traduction automatique constituerait un risque de crédibilité plutôt qu'une commodité : l'original anglais est donc servi intégralement jusqu'à ce qu'une traduction révisée existe.
At a glance
- United States, state and federal
- State common law and statute · FAR (contrast only)
- Eight states verified from statutory text · eight reported by secondary sources only · case law secondary
Key facts
- 01
Default position
Presumptively enforceable at common law in most states, subject to exceptions.
- 02
Federal contracting
Not a feature of standard FAR contracting: a CO cannot waive FAR 52.242-14 / 52.243-4 remedies.
- 03
Strongest common-law exception
Bad faith / active interference: includes refusal to issue warranted time extensions.
- 04
Broadest statutory ban
Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.62(C): public and private, no unreasonableness qualifier.
- 05
States reaching private contracts
Ohio, Washington, Kentucky: the exception to the public-works-only pattern.
- 06
Verified statute states
California, Ohio, Washington, Virginia, Oregon, Minnesota, Missouri, Kentucky (8).
- 07
Secondary-source-only states
Colorado, Louisiana, North Carolina, Kansas, Nevada, New Jersey, Arizona, Indiana (8), unverified.
- 08
2024–2026 legislative activity
No new NDFD statute enacted. Energy went to retainage caps (NY SB 5655, CA SB 61).
No-damage-for-delay is the single largest axis of intra-US variation in delay law. The identical clause, in the identical form contract, can be fully enforceable on a project in Houston and void as a matter of public policy on a project in Cleveland. An article, or a claim strategy, that does not name the state has not scoped itself.
The general position
NDFD clauses are presumptively enforceable at common law in most US jurisdictions, subject to a set of judicially created exceptions and, in a minority of states, to statutory override. There is no federal common law of NDFD for private work and no uniform national rule: enforceability is decided state by state, and within a state it can turn on whether the project is public or private.
NDFD is not a feature of standard federal construction contracting. FAR 52.242-14 (Suspension of Work) and FAR 52.243-4 (Changes) supply remedies that a Contracting Officer cannot waive by contract drafting. There is no federal analogue to a state NDFD clause sitting inside the standard FAR delay machinery. [GAP, not in corpus: a district court has reportedly held NDFD clauses per se enforceable on federally funded works in California where federal contracting rules displace state law, but the corpus flags this as headline-only and unverified, so it is not asserted here as fact.]
The common-law exceptions
Even where no statute applies, an NDFD clause is not absolute. US courts recognize a set of exceptions that let a contractor recover delay damages despite the clause:
- Bad faith, active interference, fraud or misrepresentation: the most widely adopted exception, and the one most often successfully invoked. Some jurisdictions extend it to gross negligence. Courts have found active interference in specific owner directives disrupting sequence, administrative mismanagement, an excessive volume of changes, denial of site access, failure to coordinate separate contractors, and refusal to issue warranted time extensions. See Port of Houston Authority v. Zachry Construction Corp.1 (Tex.). This is the same active-interference ground discussed as the NDFD escape hatch in the prevention-principle analysis, and is not re-derived here. See the related article on prevention and time at large.
- Delay not contemplated by the parties: an NDFD clause covers only delay that is reasonably foreseeable, arises from the contractor's work during performance, or is mentioned in the contract: Corinno Civetta Constr. Corp. v. City of New York, 67 N.Y.2d 297 (1986)2, the leading US authority. Many jurisdictions reject this exception outright.
- Delay so unreasonable in length or duration that it amounts to abandonment of the contract.
- Fundamental breach or failure of a condition precedent to performance. Rarely applied.
- The clause does not by its terms cover the delay: strict construction against the drafter.
- Third-party beneficiary limits: a clause protecting the owner does not automatically protect a construction manager, design professional, or upstream contractor not named in it.
- Waiver or estoppel arising from owner conduct, approvals, or representations.
The contractor's own failure to give contractual notice of delay is a complete answer in most jurisdictions, and is expressly preserved by every state anti-NDFD statute surveyed below.
The statute survey
Roughly half the states have gone further than the common-law exceptions and enacted a statute voiding or limiting NDFD clauses outright, typically for public work. The corpus draws a hard evidentiary line between statutes verified against statutory text and statutes reported only by secondary sources. That line is preserved below rather than flattened into one undifferentiated list.
Do not read "public work only" as the rule across the board. Ohio, Washington and Kentucky are explicit exceptions that reach private contracts too.
Verified from statutory text
| State | Citation | Scope | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| California | Cal. Pub. Contract Code § 71023 | Public agency contracts and subcontracts thereunder | Void where delay is unreasonable and not within the parties' contemplation. Agencies cannot require waiver of the section. Preserves notice, arbitration/settlement and liquidated damages |
| Ohio | Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.62(C)(1)–(2)4 | Public and private. Prime contracts and subcontracts | Void as against public policy where delay is a proximate result of the owner's act or failure to act, with no "unreasonableness" qualifier, the broadest ban in the US |
| Washington | RCW 4.24.3605 | Public and private construction contracts | Void and unenforceable for unreasonable delay caused by the contractee. Preserves notice, arbitration/settlement and reasonable liquidated damages |
| Virginia | Va. Code § 2.2-4335(A)6 | Public construction contracts | Void for unreasonable delay caused by acts or omissions within the public body's control, (B) preserves the public body's own recovery, notice, LDs and dispute procedures. Leading case: Blake Constr. Co./Poole & Kent v. Upper Occoquan Sewage Auth., 587 S.E.2d 711 (Va. 2003)7 |
| Oregon | ORS 279C.3158 | Public improvement contracts | Void for unreasonable delay caused by the contracting agency. Preserves notice, arbitration/settlement and reasonable LDs |
| Minnesota | Minn. Stat. § 15.4119 | Public works contracts, state and political subdivisions | Subd. 2 voids waivers of costs, damages or equitable adjustment for entity-caused delay. Subd. 4 preserves notice, reasonable LDs and arbitration |
| Missouri | Mo. Rev. Stat. § 8.96210 (post-2022. Formerly § 34.058) | Public works contracts, state, counties, cities and political subdivisions, excluding MoDOT | Void where delay is within the public entity's control. Preserves contractor-caused-delay limits, notice, reasonable LDs and arbitration |
| Kentucky | KRS § 371.405(2)(d)11 (Kentucky Fairness in Construction Act) | Public and private | Void: a provision purporting to waive a contractor's right to costs, additional time, or damages for delay within the contracting entity's control. Notice and claim-preservation requirements are not barred by the KFCA. The statute kills the clause, not the time bar |
Reported by secondary sources only: verify before citing
| State | Citation | Reported effect |
|---|---|---|
| Colorado | Colo. Rev. Stat. § 24-91-103.512 | Public contracts. Voids NDFD for delay caused by the public entity. Citation confirmed by two independent secondary sources. Statutory text not retrieved |
| Louisiana | La. R.S. 38:2216(H)13 | Public contracts. Voids NDFD. [UNVERIFIED] |
| North Carolina | N.C. Gen. Stat. § 143-134.314 | Public contracts. Unenforceable only where delay is caused solely by the owner or its agent, narrower than most |
| Kansas | Kan. Stat. Ann. § 16-190715 | Public contracts. Void, unenforceable, against public policy. [UNVERIFIED] |
| Nevada | Nev. Rev. Stat. § 338.48516 | Public contracts. Unenforceable for unreasonable-length delay or delay from fraud, active interference or scope additions. Private contracts generally enforceable. [UNVERIFIED] |
| New Jersey | N.J. Stat. Ann. § 2A:58B-317 | Public contracts. Unenforceable where the entity's negligence, bad faith, active interference or other tortious conduct caused the delay. [UNVERIFIED] |
| Arizona | A.R.S. § 41-261718 | State governmental contracts. Does not void NDFD outright. Requires a negotiation provision for unreasonable owner-caused delay not within contemplation. [UNVERIFIED] |
| Indiana | No citation located19 | Reported as prohibited for unforeseen conditions encountered during a project. [UNVERIFIED] No citation given by the source. |
Correcting two circulating errors
Rhode Island has no located NDFD statute. No citation was found despite the search. A construction compendium for the state does not discuss NDFD clauses at all, and a widely circulated 50-state matrix lists Rhode Island among states with no case law on the subject. Rhode Island does have separate statutes on construction indemnity and anti-lien-waiver, but those are different subject matter entirely. Rhode Island appears in several circulating NDFD lists in error: treat any list that shows it as a statutory-ban state as wrong unless a citation is produced. The negative finding is itself the useful fact here.
Oregon is also miscategorized by at least one matrix. The same widely circulated matrix that mislists Rhode Island erroneously groups Oregon among "generally enforceable / no case law" states, but ORS 279C.315, cited in the table above, is on the books and belongs in the verified column, not the unenforceable-with-no-authority one.
Three state decisions the corpus was missing
| Decision | Point |
|---|---|
| Scoccolo Construction v City of Renton, 158 Wn.2d 506 (Wash.)20 | A utility "acting for" the owner voids the NDFD clause. Directly useful wherever third-party utility delay is in play, and an under-cited point |
| Plato General Construction v Dormitory Authority of the State of New York21 | Narrows Corinno Civetta sharply. Do not cite Corinno Civetta's "delay not contemplated" exception in New York without reading Plato first |
| Asset Recovery Contracting, LLC v Walsh Construction Co.22 (Ill.) | Sets out Illinois's four exceptions. The cleanest single-state statement of the exception structure |
And the Kentucky refinement, now pinned to a subsection: the KFCA kills the NDFD clause, but notice and claim-preservation requirements survive and are strictly enforced under KRS § 371.405(3)(b), a separate subsection from the delay-waiver ban itself (see the Kentucky row in the verified table above).
What 2024–2026 did not bring
No new state statute voiding or limiting NDFD clauses was enacted in 2024, 2025, or the first seven months of 2026. The legislative energy in that window went elsewhere: New York SB 5655 (signed December 2025) and California SB 61 (effective January 2026) both cap retention at 5%. Those bills matter to cash flow during a delay dispute, but they are retainage and prompt-payment law, not NDFD law, and should not be conflated with the subject of this survey.
Practice notes
Notice compliance is analyzed separately. See the notice-and-time-bars article in this cluster for the mechanics of what a valid notice requires and when the clock starts.
Sources and authorities
- *Verification, unless noted
Verified from statutory text
- 1Port of Houston Authority v Zachry Construction Corp.(Tex.). Reporter citation not supplied by the source
Active interference, including refusal to issue warranted time extensions, as an exception to an NDFD clause.
- 2Corinno Civetta Constr. Corp. v City of New York67 N.Y.2d 297 (1986)
The leading US authority for the "delay not contemplated by the parties" exception to NDFD clauses. Many jurisdictions reject this exception.
- 3California: Cal. Pub. Contract Code § 7102Cal. Pub. Contract Code § 7102 (am. Stats. 1987, ch. 98, § 1)
Public agency construction contracts and subcontracts thereunder: clauses limiting recovery to a time extension do not preclude damages for unreasonable, uncontemplated delay. Agencies cannot require waiver of the section. Preserves notice, arbitration/settlement and liquidated damages.
- 4Ohio: Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.62(C)(1)-(2)Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.62(C)(1), (C)(2) (eff. 22 Mar 2001)
Public and private, prime contracts and subcontracts: void and unenforceable as against public policy where the delay is a proximate result of the owner's act or failure to act, with no "unreasonableness" qualifier, the broadest ban in the US.
- 5Washington: RCW 4.24.360RCW 4.24.360
Public and private construction contracts: clauses waiving damages or an equitable adjustment for unreasonable delay caused by the contractee are void and unenforceable as against public policy. The statute preserves notice, arbitration/settlement and reasonable liquidated damages.
- 6Virginia: Va. Code § 2.2-4335(A)Va. Code § 2.2-4335(A)
Public construction contracts: void as against public policy for unreasonable delay caused by acts or omissions of the public body within its control, (B) preserves the public body's own recovery, notice, LDs and dispute procedures.
- 7Blake Constr. Co./Poole & Kent v Upper Occoquan Sewage Auth.587 S.E.2d 711 (Va. 2003)
Leading Virginia case applying Va. Code § 2.2-4335(A)'s NDFD override.
- 8Oregon: ORS 279C.315ORS 279C.315
Public improvement contracts: void for unreasonable delay caused by the contracting agency. Preserves notice, arbitration/settlement and reasonable liquidated damages.
- 9Minnesota: Minn. Stat. § 15.411Minn. Stat. § 15.411 (2002 Minn. Laws ch. 299, § 1)
Public works contracts of the state and political subdivisions: subd. 2 voids clauses waiving rights to costs, damages or an equitable adjustment for entity-caused delay. Subd. 4 preserves notice, reasonable LDs and arbitration.
- 10Missouri: Mo. Rev. Stat. § 8.962Mo. Rev. Stat. § 8.962 (post-2022. Formerly § 34.058)
Public works contracts of the state, counties, cities and political subdivisions, excluding MoDOT: void where delay is within the contracting public entity's control. Preserves contractor-caused-delay limits, notice, reasonable LDs and arbitration.
- 11Kentucky: KRS § 371.405(2)(d) (Kentucky Fairness in Construction Act)KRS § 371.405(2)(d)
Public and private: void a provision purporting to waive a contractor's or subcontractor's right to costs, additional time, or damages, or an equitable adjustment, for delay within the contracting entity's control. Claim-preservation and notice requirements are not barred by the KFCA and are strictly enforced, and that survival is itself pinned to a separate subsection, KRS § 371.405(3)(b).
- 12Colorado: Colo. Rev. Stat. § 24-91-103.5Colo. Rev. Stat. § 24-91-103.5
Reported to void NDFD in public contracts where the delay is caused by the contracting public entity.
- 13Louisiana: La. R.S. 38:2216(H)La. R.S. 38:2216(H)
Reported to void NDFD in public contracts.
- 14North Carolina: N.C. Gen. Stat. § 143-134.3N.C. Gen. Stat. § 143-134.3
Public contracts: unenforceable only where delay is caused solely by the owner or its agent, narrower than most states in the survey.
- 15Kansas: Kan. Stat. Ann. § 16-1907Kan. Stat. Ann. § 16-1907
Reported void, unenforceable and against public policy for public contracts.
- 16Nevada: Nev. Rev. Stat. § 338.485Nev. Rev. Stat. § 338.485
Public contracts: reported unenforceable for unreasonable-length delay or delay from fraud, active interference or scope additions. Private contracts generally enforceable.
- 17New Jersey: N.J. Stat. Ann. § 2A:58B-3N.J. Stat. Ann. § 2A:58B-3
Public contracts: reported unenforceable where the entity's negligence, bad faith, active interference or other tortious conduct caused the delay.
- 18Arizona: A.R.S. § 41-2617A.R.S. § 41-2617
State governmental contracts: does not void NDFD outright. Requires a provision obliging the parties to negotiate recovery for unreasonable, uncontemplated owner-caused delay.
- 19Indiana: no citation locatedNot supplied by the source
Reported as prohibited "in the case of unforeseen conditions encountered during a project". No statutory citation given.
- 20Scoccolo Construction, Inc. v City of Renton158 Wn.2d 506 (Wash.)
A utility "acting for" the owner falls inside the NDFD clause's scope for purposes of voiding it: third-party utility delay is not automatically outside an NDFD clause's reach just because the utility itself isn't the owner.
- 21Plato General Construction Corp. v Dormitory Authority of the State of New York(N.Y.)
Sharply narrows the Corinno Civetta "delay not contemplated by the parties" exception. A court should not apply Corinno Civetta's exception in New York without reading Plato first.
- 22Asset Recovery Contracting, LLC v Walsh Construction Co.(Ill.)
Sets out Illinois's four common-law exceptions to NDFD enforceability: the cleanest single-state statement of the exception structure in the corpus.
General information, not legal advice. Reviewed 1 sept. 2026. Spotted an error? info@storiatechnologies.com
The notice brief
One email a month on claims, notices and the cases that decided them.
This month: three notice clocks and their judgments.
- 01Notice and time bars in OntarioIn Ontario a contractual notice of delay is a condition precedent: miss it and the claim is…
- 02Notice and time bars in AustraliaAustralian EOT time bars are enforceable conditions precedent everywhere, subject to the…
- 03Modèles d'avis de retard pour l'AS 4000, le FIDIC 2017 et le CCDC 2Un avis de retard consigne un seul fait, en temps utile : qu'un événement a retardé, ou…
Each issue links to the full articles in the Storia Library.