Saltar al contenido principal

Privacidad

Tu privacidad

Las cookies esenciales mantienen este sitio en funcionamiento. Los análisis opcionales nos ayudan a comprender qué funciona y solo se habilitan si usted acepta.

LIBRARY
Estados UnidosExtension of timeJurisdiction article

There Is No Prevention Principle in US Construction Law

US law has no doctrine called "the prevention principle" and no concept of "time at large." A practitioner trained in English law looking for either will find neither. The same commercial result, that an owner who caused delay cannot profit from it, is reached instead through LD non-apportionment, the implied duty not to hinder, and Spearin.

Reviewed 1 sept 20265 min read10 sources
Same topic inBCUS

Disponible solo en inglés Este artículo aún no se ha traducido. Los plazos, el derecho a reclamar y el procedimiento descritos aquí rozan lo jurídico, y una traducción automática sería un riesgo de credibilidad más que una comodidad: por eso se sirve el original inglés íntegro hasta que exista una traducción revisada.

At a glance

Estados Unidos
Jurisdiction
United States, federal and state
Governing regimes
AIA A201-2017 · FAR
Evidence basis
FAR clause numbers/dates from acquisition.gov. Case law from secondary sources
§ 00

Key facts

  1. 01

    No prevention principle

    US law has no doctrine by that name and no concept of time at large: three functional equivalents reach the same result instead.

  2. 02

    LD non-apportionment

    In a minority but significant group of states, an owner responsible for any portion of the delay forfeits the entire LD entitlement absent an apportionment clause.

  3. 03

    AIA A201-2017 gap

    Contains no apportionment provision, so an unamended A201 leaves the owner exposed in a non-apportionment state.

  4. 04

    Federal practice

    Sits with apportionment, not forfeiture. FAR 52.211-13 contemplates equitable adjustment of LDs.

  5. 05

    Federal burden

    Sauer puts the burden of proving the extent of excusable delay on the contractor. Prove nothing, remit nothing.

  6. 06

    Implied duty not to hinder

    Breach of the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing converts a neutral delay into an owner-caused, compensable one.

  7. 07

    Spearin as a delay case

    Work was suspended roughly 15 months on its facts, the doctrinal bridge from defective drawings to compensable delay.

  8. 08

    Sovereign acts doctrine

    The federal-specific inversion: a tariff or regulatory measure is excusable but not compensable.

Neither "the prevention principle" nor "time at large" is a US doctrine. A practitioner trained in English law will look for the wrong thing: there is no rule under which an owner's uncovered delay discharges the completion date and converts the contractor's obligation into one to complete within a reasonable time. US law reaches the same commercial result, that an owner who caused delay cannot keep collecting liquidated damages for it and a contractor delayed by the owner can claim its costs, through three separate, unrelated doctrines.

§ 01

The liquidated-damages non-apportionment rule

This is the closest US analogue, and it is the most powerful of the three. In a minority but significant group of states, if the owner is responsible for any portion of the delay and the contract contains no apportionment clause, the owner does not suffer a pro-rata reduction. It loses the entire LD entitlement. North Carolina states the rule squarely: liquidated damages are unenforceable if the party benefiting from them was itself responsible for a portion of the delay, unless the contract contains a clause providing for apportionment. Biemann & Rowell Co. v Donohoe Cos., 556 S.E.2d 1 (N.C. Ct. App. 2001)1.

There is a recognized trend away from the all-or-nothing rule, toward judicial apportionment of delay days where the evidence permits it. But where non-apportionment still governs, the drafting consequence is sharp: a contractor's most valuable defensive move is not attacking the LD rate as a penalty. It is proving one day of owner-caused critical-path delay. An owner in such a state must insist on an express apportionment clause, because AIA A201-2017 contains no apportionment provision. An unamended A201 in a non-apportionment state leaves the owner badly exposed.

State non-apportionment

Forfeiture of the whole LD entitlement

A minority-but-significant group of states: any owner-caused delay, absent an apportionment clause, voids the entire LD entitlement. A state common-law doctrine operating on private and state-law LD clauses.

Federal apportionment

A day-for-day remit, on proof

Federal practice sits with apportionment instead. FAR 52.211-13, Time Extensions2 contemplates that a change order may provide equitable adjustments to liquidated damages under revised schedules, and boards remit day-for-day, but Sauer Inc. v Danzig, 224 F.3d 1340, 1351 (Fed. Cir. 2000)3 puts the burden of proving the extent of the excusable delay on the contractor. Prove nothing, remit nothing.

These are two different mechanisms and should not be read as the same rule wearing two hats: state non-apportionment is common-law forfeiture triggered by any owner fault. Federal apportionment is a proportional remit that still depends on the contractor discharging its own proof burden.

§ 02

The implied duty not to hinder or interfere

Every US construction contract carries an implied duty of good faith and fair dealing, and with it a duty not to hinder or interfere with the other party's performance. Breach converts an otherwise neutral delay into an owner-caused, compensable one. In Stormwater Plans, LLC, ASBCA 63284 [appeal number cross-check advised] / ASBCA 63900, 63901 (10 April 2025)4, a breach-of-the-implied-duty-not-to-hinder-or-interfere theory survived dismissal on allegations of design issues and approval delays, a live pleading route in federal practice, not a theoretical one.

§ 03

Spearin, reframed as a delay case

United States v Spearin is usually cited for the implied warranty of design adequacy: the government's specifications for a sewer relocation carried a warranty that, if complied with, the sewer would be adequate. United States v Spearin, 248 U.S. 132, 137 (1918)5. But the facts underlying that holding are a delay case. After the relocated sewer failed and flooded the dry-dock site, work was suspended for roughly 15 months while Spearin declined to proceed until the Government accepted responsibility. The Court held Spearin was not obliged to restore the sewer and proceed at his peril, and that the Government's annulment of the contract was wrongful.

Where the owner furnishes design, defective or incomplete specifications are an owner-caused, compensable delay event. The contractor need only show it complied with the specifications and they were inadequate, not that the owner was negligent. That is the doctrinal bridge from "the drawings were wrong" to "the delay is compensable."

Spearin has also been applied to private contracts, which is why it functions as a third, independent route to the prevention result rather than a federal-only curiosity.

§ 04

Spearin in design-build, and where it stops

Spearin survives in design-build, but it relocates: Balfour Beatty v GSA6 holds that bridging documents at only 30% completion can still qualify as design specifications carrying the warranty, and Sheffield Korte7, certiorari denied 12 January 2026, further qualifies how Spearin applies once a design-builder takes on design responsibility itself. This was the most-litigated open question in US design-build practice. Both decisions now give it an answer.

The warranty has a real limit, though. Dugan & Meyers Construction Co. v Ohio Dept of Administrative Services8 refused to extend Spearin to plan-change delay and enforced a 10-day notice bar against the contractor. Its no-damage-for-delay holding is superseded by Ohio's later statutory ban (Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.62(C), see No-damage-for-delay clauses), but the Spearin limit itself stands: the design warranty is not a substitute for complying with the contract's own notice mechanics.

§ 05

Active interference: the NDFD escape hatch

Where a no-damage-for-delay clause applies, the functional prevention argument becomes the active interference / bad faith exception, the most widely adopted NDFD exception across US jurisdictions. Active interference has been found in specific owner directives disrupting sequence, administrative mismanagement, an excessive volume of changes, denial of site access, failure to coordinate separate contractors, and, directly on point here, refusal to issue warranted time extensions. Port of Houston Authority v Zachry Construction Corp. (Tex.)9. The full state-by-state NDFD exception landscape, including the enforceability variation across public and private contracts, is covered on the no-damage-for-delay spoke rather than repeated here.

§ 06

The federal-specific inversion: sovereign acts

FAR 52.249-10(b) lists acts of the Government in either its sovereign or contractual capacity as an excusable cause of delay. FAR 52.249-10(b)10. But the sovereign acts doctrine bars treating the Government-as-sovereign's general regulatory action as a breach by the Government-as-contractor. A tariff or a regulatory measure is therefore excusable but not compensable, the mirror image of a prevention analysis, where owner-caused delay is precisely what unlocks compensation rather than what forecloses it.

Notes

Sources and authorities

10 cited
  1. *
    Verification, unless noted

    Secondary source. Not independently re-verified this pass.

  2. 1
    Biemann & Rowell Co. v Donohoe Cos.556 S.E.2d 1 (N.C. Ct. App. 2001)

    States the LD non-apportionment rule squarely: liquidated damages are unenforceable where the party benefiting from them was itself responsible for a portion of the delay, absent an apportionment clause.

    Buscar en CourtListener

  3. 2
    FAR 52.211-13: Time ExtensionsFAR 52.211-13

    Contemplates that a change order may provide equitable adjustments to liquidated damages under revised schedules. Federal practice sits with apportionment, not forfeiture.

    Buscar en acquisition.gov

  4. 3
    Sauer Inc. v Danzig224 F.3d 1340, 1351 (Fed. Cir. 2000)

    Puts the burden of proving the extent of excusable delay, for liquidated-damages remission purposes, on the contractor.

    Buscar en CourtListener

  5. 4
    Stormwater Plans, LLCASBCA 63284 [appeal number cross-check advised] / ASBCA 63900, 63901 (10 April 2025)

    A breach-of-the-implied-duty-not-to-hinder-or-interfere theory survived dismissal on allegations of design issues and approval delays, a live pleading route in federal practice.

    Buscar en ASBCA

  6. 5
    United States v Spearin248 U.S. 132, 137-38 (1918)

    Government-furnished specifications carried a warranty of adequacy. On the facts, a delay case, because the contractor was not obliged to restore defective work and proceed at its peril after roughly 15 months of suspension.

    Buscar en CourtListener

  7. 6
    Balfour Beatty v GSA(Fed. Cir., 13 March 2025)

    Bridging documents at only 30% design completion can still qualify as design specifications carrying the Spearin warranty. Spearin survives in design-build but relocates to whichever documents the design-builder didn't itself finish.

    Buscar en CourtListener

  8. 7
    Sheffield Kortecert. denied 12 January 2026

    Further qualifies how Spearin applies once a design-builder takes on design responsibility itself, one of the two decisions that answered the most-litigated open question in US design-build practice.

  9. 8
    Dugan & Meyers Construction Co. v Ohio Dept of Administrative Services113 Ohio St. 3d 226 (2007)

    The Ohio Supreme Court refused to extend Spearin to plan-change delay and enforced a 10-day contractual notice bar against the contractor. Its no-damage-for-delay holding is superseded by Ohio's later statutory ban (Ohio Rev. Code § 4113.62(C)), but the Spearin limit itself stands: the design warranty is not a substitute for complying with the contract's own notice mechanics.

    Buscar en CourtListener

  10. 9
    Port of Houston Authority v Zachry Construction Corp.(Tex.). Reporter citation not supplied by the source

    Cited for the active-interference exception, including refusal to issue warranted time extensions as a recognized instance of it.

  11. 10
    FAR 52.249-10(b): excusable-delay listFAR 52.249-10(b)

    Lists acts of the Government in either its sovereign or contractual capacity as excusable causes of delay. The sovereign acts doctrine then makes sovereign-capacity acts excusable but not compensable.

    Buscar en acquisition.gov

General information, not legal advice. Reviewed 1 sept 2026. Spotted an error? info@storiatechnologies.com

Newsletter · monthly

The notice brief

One email a month on claims, notices and the cases that decided them.

One email a month. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share your address.

The notice briefIssue 01 · sample

This month: three notice clocks and their judgments.

  1. 01
    Notice and time bars in OntarioIn Ontario a contractual notice of delay is a condition precedent: miss it and the claim is…
  2. 02
    Notice and time bars in AustraliaAustralian EOT time bars are enforceable conditions precedent everywhere, subject to the…
  3. 03
    Modelos de aviso de retraso para AS 4000, FIDIC 2017 y CCDC 2Un aviso de retraso deja constancia a tiempo de un solo hecho: que algo ha retrasado, o…

Each issue links to the full articles in the Storia Library.

Prevención y plazo indeterminado en los Estados Unidos · Storia